I recently met with a home gardener who brought in tomato plants showing strange symptoms on the leaves.  Together we puzzled over the odd leaf-curling symptoms that were affecting their tomato beds, but not other areas of the garden. Upon further investigation it was revealed that hay, used as mulch, had recently been spread around the tomatoes, but not in other areas of the garden. It quickly became apparent that the symptoms were likely related to herbicide residual on the hay that was used. The herbicide aminopyralid was the potential culprit. In this case the residual herbicide was not enough to outright kill the growing tomato plants. However, it was interfering with their growth and development and is a cautionary tale reminding us how important careful sourcing of hay used in mulch or compost can be.

Twisted and cupped tomato leaves

New growth on tomato plants showing herbicide damage symptoms likely a result of residual aminopyralid or similar herbicide.

What is aminopyralid and how does residual herbicide affect non-target plants?

Aminopyralid is a herbicide active ingredient found in several popular pasture products such as GrazonNext™, Milestone™, Chapparral™ and similar products. This and other similar chemicals have residual activity and can be retained in plant tissues, animal manure, and soil, which makes them a very useful for controlling certain troublesome broadleaf weeds in grass pastures for an extended period of time. Unfortunately, this residual activity increases the potential for causing trouble in vegetables or other crops when hay or animal manure from aminopyralid treated pastures is mistakenly used for mulch, compost, etc. In Florida, aminopyralid containing pasture herbicides are often used as the “go to” for control of hard to control weeds like horsenettle and tropical soda apple which are potentially toxic to livestock. Tomatoes, potatoes, and eggplant are in the same genus (Solanum) as those weeds and are therefore very susceptible to this herbicide as are many other vegetable and other broadleaf crops.

How can I know if hay is safe to be used for mulch or compost?

Before acquiring hay to be used as mulch or to compost for vegetable beds, be sure to ask if the hay is free of herbicides with residual activity. What was sprayed on the field in the last two seasons before the hay was harvested. Given that hay destined to be used as mulch or compost is usually old and spoiled, management history of a particular hay bale is likely to be hard to pin down. Do not trust hay to be used for mulch or compost in vegetable beds, if prior spray management details are unknown. Also consider that well-stored hay will retain residual herbicide better and for a longer period of time than weathered hay, as the active ingredient is less subject to weathering and biological breakdown.

Herbicide management history of older, forgotten about hay may be difficult to find out.

Hay producers who use broadleaf herbicide products with residual activity such as those containing aminopyralid should always follow herbicide label guidelines. Remember, “the label is the law!” For instance, supplemental labeling of GrazonNext HL™ (including FL, AL, and GA) indicates that hay/straw from fields sprayed in the past 18 months should not be used for compost, mulch, or mushroom spawn. Refer to the label of the particular herbicide product you use for any restrictions. As well, relevant use restrictions and considerations like in the previous examples should be conveyed to hay buyers.

Perhaps you already have some hay for mulch/compost with an unclear management history, or you would like to double-check and be sure that it is safe. How could one test it to see if it was safe to use?  There is a test called a “bioassay”, conducted by growing susceptible plants like tomatoes or beans in small pots with the hay/compost/mulch in question incorporated into the potting soil to see if any herbicide symptoms develop in the test plants, before using the hay over a larger area or garden where there would be more risk. For more information on how to conduct a bioassay see: Herbicide Residues, in Manure, Compost, or Hay. Similar in-field bioassays are also recommended when rotating areas out of pasture and into row crops when pasture herbicides with residual activity were used. If susceptible row crops like peanuts are grown in areas where such herbicides were used in the recent past they can be damaged. Follow the link to an older post for more information.

When used according to label instructions, herbicides with residual activity are very useful for control of broad-leafed weeds in pasture and hay fields and may reduce the spread weeds through seed coming in on purchased hay. However, problems can emerge when hay from fields treated with these products change hands without the use restrictions and considerations being adequately explained. Therefore, caution should be taken by both producer and buyer in order to avoid damaging sensitive crops when hay or livestock manure are used for mulch or compost.

For more information, using the following publication link
Herbicide Residues in Manure, Compost, or Hay
Kacey Aukema